no-mistakes(review): Harden health-check provenance, infisical verification, report-only JSON, tests

docs/probe-drift-round2-evidence.md

@@ -72,8 +72,8 @@ Root causes (all stale expectations; no live fault):
 |---|---|
 | `ct-unreachable:koby:192.168.68.15` | CT 111 (tdunna/koby) runs on **storepve (.6)**, not amdpve (.15). |
 | `wrapper-*:abiba` | Abiba is pi-only since the harness purge. `/root/.local/bin/hermes` is a dangling symlink; no `hermes-real`, no `~/.hermes/.env`. |
-| `wrapper-*:koby` | Koby is **report-only** (captain ruling 2026-08-17, Rule 17): detect and report, never repair — its legs must not count as fleet failures. |
-| `wrapper-infisical-path:koonimo` | Koonimo's wrapper injects `KOONIMO_LITELLM_API_KEY` from `~/.hermes/.env` and never invokes infisical. The check required `/usr/bin/infisical`, which is only one valid mechanism. |
+| `wrapper-*:koby` | Koby is **report-only** (captain ruling 2026-08-17, Rule 17): detect and report, never repair — its legs must not count as fleet failures. Koby's wrapper is also the genuine no-infisical case: it sources `~/.hermes/.env` rather than `/usr/bin/infisical`, which the check now accepts. |
+| `wrapper-infisical-path:koonimo` | Koonimo's wrapper **does** reference `/usr/bin/infisical` — but past the old check's `head -20` window, so the check looked for the path in the wrong slice and false-failed. The fix that mattered was reading the full wrapper body (and then verifying any absolute infisical path it finds actually exists). |
 
 **After** — same absolute path, `python3 scripts/agent-health-check.py --no-deploy` (v4):
 

infrastructure-monitoring.prose.md

@@ -103,14 +103,22 @@ GPU .8 (RTX 3090)    GPU .110 (RTX 5070)   GPU .15 (Strix Halo)
 
 ## Execution
 
-### Liveness rule (any-HTTP-response)
+### Liveness rule (scoped)
 
-A probe is **ALIVE** if the endpoint returns **ANY** HTTP status — including
-`401`/`403` auth challenges and `3xx` redirects. A bare `200` is not required and
-must never be a pass condition for an auth-gated endpoint. **DOWN = connection
-refused (`000`) or timeout only.** Same rule as zulip-health (Tanko) and
-gpu-monitor. The PVE API (`:8006/api2/json`) legitimately answers `401` to an
-unauthenticated probe — that is the healthy signal, not a failure.
+The any-HTTP-response rule applies ONLY to unauthenticated/auth-gated endpoints,
+where any HTTP answer proves a listener is up: the PVE API
+(`https://<node>:8006/api2/json/version`) and LiteLLM health
+(`/litellm/health`, `301` → `/litellm/health/liveliness`). For those endpoints a
+probe is **ALIVE** on **ANY** HTTP status — `401`/`403` auth challenges and `3xx`
+redirects included — and **DOWN = connection refused (`000`) or timeout only**.
+The PVE API legitimately answers `401` to an unauthenticated probe — that is the
+healthy signal, not a failure. Same scoped rule as zulip-health (Tanko) and
+gpu-monitor.
+
+Probes whose success condition is specifically a bare `200` are NOT covered by
+the any-HTTP rule. On those — the authenticated Zulip POST and the router
+`/health` — an unexpected status (`401`/`403` from a bad or missing credential,
+`5xx`, or anything other than the expected `200`) is an **ALERT**, not "alive".
 
 ### check-health
 
@@ -172,10 +180,13 @@ curl -s http://192.168.68.116:4001/metrics | head -20
 **Report format**: Begin every report with the **absolute path the probe executed
 from** (`pwd -P`, or the script's absolute path) so a stale-consumer report is
 distinguishable from a real fault at read time. Summarize actual results from
-each probe. Apply the any-HTTP-response liveness rule above: only
-connection-refused (`000`) or timeout is DOWN; empty output is a warning. A probe
-that requires a bare `200` on an auth-gated endpoint (PVE API → `401`, LiteLLM
-health → `301` redirect) is a stale expectation, not a fault.
+each probe. Apply the any-HTTP-response liveness rule ONLY to the auth-gated PVE
+API and LiteLLM endpoints above: only connection-refused (`000`) or timeout is
+DOWN; empty output is a warning. For probes whose expected result is a bare `200`
+(the authenticated Zulip POST, router `/health`), flag an alert on any unexpected
+status (`401`/`403`/`5xx`) — do not summarize it as alive. A bare-`200`
+expectation on the auth-gated PVE API (`401`) or LiteLLM health (`301` redirect)
+is a stale expectation, not a fault.
 
 
 ### Phase 1: GPU Exporters

scripts/agent-health-check.py

@@ -32,14 +32,21 @@ Changelog:
     2026-08-17 ruling: every koby leg is detected and reported, never counted as a
     fleet failure and never repaired. koby's PVE mapping corrected to storepve
     (CT 111 tdunna lives on .6 — the old amdpve mapping produced a false
-    ct-unreachable). The wrapper infisical-path check no longer FAILs .env-based
-    wrappers that legitimately never invoke infisical (koonimo/baggy). Every run
-    now prints absolute execution provenance (script + cwd) in the header and in
-    --json output so a stale-consumer report is distinguishable from a fault at
-    read time.
+    ct-unreachable). The wrapper infisical-path check had two stale-expectation
+    bugs: it read only the first 20 lines of the wrapper, so koonimo (whose
+    wrapper does reference /usr/bin/infisical, just past line 20) was falsely
+    FAILed as "path may be wrong"; and it treated the absence of any infisical
+    reference as a fault, though koby's wrapper sources the key from
+    ~/.hermes/.env and never invokes infisical. The check now reads the full
+    wrapper body, accepts a no-infisical wrapper, and verifies that any absolute
+    infisical path the wrapper references actually exists. Report-only findings
+    are surfaced in a machine-readable `report_only` array in --json output,
+    separate from `failures`. Every run prints absolute execution provenance
+    (script + cwd) in the header, in the cron ALERT line, and in --json output so
+    a stale-consumer report is distinguishable from a fault at read time.
 """
 
-import subprocess, json, sys, os, time
+import subprocess, json, sys, os, time, re
 from datetime import datetime
 
 LITELLM = "http://192.168.68.116:80"
@@ -88,6 +95,7 @@ GPU_HOSTS = {
 }
 
 FAIL = []
+REPORT_ONLY = []
 
 
 def _fail(key, agent_name=None):
@@ -95,11 +103,13 @@ def _fail(key, agent_name=None):
 
     Koby is report-only per the captain's 2026-08-17 ruling (Rule 17): its legs
     are detected and reported, never repaired and never counted as fleet
-    failures. A red fleet alert on a known report-only leg is a false alarm. Any
-    non-report-only agent (or a leg with no agent, e.g. GPU hosts) records
-    normally.
+    failures. A red fleet alert on a known report-only leg is a false alarm.
+    Report-only findings are tracked separately so --json consumers can still
+    see them without them counting as fleet failures. Any non-report-only agent
+    (or a leg with no agent, e.g. GPU hosts) records normally.
     """
     if agent_name and AGENTS.get(agent_name, {}).get("report_only"):
+        REPORT_ONLY.append(key)
         print(f"  🔍 report-only ({agent_name}): {key} — reported, not counted/repaired")
         return
     FAIL.append(key)
@@ -509,23 +519,44 @@ def check_wrapper_integrity():
                 print(f"  ⚠️  {name}: hermes at {wrapper.strip()} (not ~/.local/bin/hermes)")
 
         # Credential-injection mechanism. The Hermes-era wrapper injected creds
-        # with `/usr/bin/infisical run`; newer wrappers source the agent key from
-        # ~/.hermes/.env and never mention infisical (koonimo/baggy does exactly
-        # this). A wrapper with NO infisical reference is therefore a valid
-        # alternate mechanism, not a fault — only flag a wrapper that DOES call
-        # infisical when the binary cannot resolve. The old check FAILed every
-        # .env-based wrapper as "infisical path may be wrong": a stale
-        # expectation, not a fault.
+        # with `/usr/bin/infisical run`, but the mechanism is not required to be
+        # infisical at all: koby's wrapper sources the key from ~/.hermes/.env
+        # and never mentions infisical, which is valid. The old check read only
+        # the first 20 lines, so koonimo's wrapper — which DOES reference
+        # /usr/bin/infisical, just past line 20 — false-failed as "path may be
+        # wrong". Read the full body, accept a no-infisical wrapper, and verify
+        # that any absolute infisical path the wrapper hardcodes actually exists
+        # (PATH resolution alone is not enough — a dangling /usr/bin/infisical is
+        # a broken wrapper even when a different infisical is on PATH).
         wrapper_body = ssh(host, "cat /root/.local/bin/hermes 2>/dev/null", user=user) or ""
         if "infisical" in wrapper_body:
+            inf_paths = []
+            for _m in re.finditer(r"(/[A-Za-z0-9._/-]*infisical)", wrapper_body):
+                if _m.group(1) not in inf_paths:
+                    inf_paths.append(_m.group(1))
+            dangling = []
+            for _p in inf_paths:
+                _exists = ssh(host, f"test -x {_p} && echo OK || echo MISS", user=user)
+                if not _exists or _exists.strip().splitlines()[-1] != "OK":
+                    dangling.append(_p)
+            if inf_paths:
+                if dangling:
+                    inf_actual = ssh(host, "command -v infisical 2>/dev/null", user=user)
+                    suffix = f" (infisical at {inf_actual})" if inf_actual else ""
+                    print(f"  ❌ {name}: wrapper hardcodes missing infisical path(s) "
+                          f"{', '.join(dangling)}{suffix}")
+                    _fail(f"wrapper-infisical-path:{name}", name)
+                elif "/usr/bin/infisical" not in wrapper_body:
+                    print(f"  ⚠️  {name}: wrapper infisical path differs — informational")
+                else:
+                    print(f"  ✅ {name}: wrapper infisical path OK")
+            else:
                 inf_actual = ssh(host, "command -v infisical 2>/dev/null", user=user)
                 if not inf_actual:
                     print(f"  ❌ {name}: wrapper invokes infisical but the binary is MISSING")
                     _fail(f"wrapper-no-infisical:{name}", name)
-            elif "/usr/bin/infisical" not in wrapper_body:
-                print(f"  ⚠️  {name}: wrapper infisical path differs (infisical at {inf_actual}) — informational")
                 else:
-                print(f"  ✅ {name}: wrapper infisical path OK")
+                    print(f"  ✅ {name}: wrapper infisical resolves via PATH ({inf_actual})")
         else:
             print(f"  ℹ️  {name}: wrapper resolves creds without infisical (e.g. ~/.hermes/.env) — OK")
 
@@ -614,14 +645,16 @@ def main():
 
     # Provenance: a report is only actionable if the reader can tell WHICH copy
     # of this script produced it. Emit the absolute execution path (script + cwd)
-    # in both human and --json output so a stale-consumer report is
-    # distinguishable from a real fault at read time.
+    # in human, cron-alert, and --json output so a stale-consumer report is
+    # distinguishable from a real fault at read time. The production cron path
+    # runs --quiet, so provenance must NOT be behind the quiet guard.
     script_path = os.path.abspath(__file__)
     cwd = os.getcwd()
 
     if not quiet:
         print(f"🏥 Agent Health Check v4 — {datetime.now().strftime('%Y-%m-%d %H:%M UTC')}")
     print(f"📍 executed from: script={script_path} cwd={cwd}")
+    if not quiet:
         print()
 
     load_agent_keys()
@@ -656,14 +689,15 @@ def main():
     if FAIL:
         print(f"\n❌ {len(FAIL)} FAILURE(S): {' | '.join(FAIL)}")
         if quiet:
-            print(f"ALERT agent-health:{','.join(FAIL)}")
+            print(f"ALERT agent-health:{','.join(FAIL)} script={script_path} cwd={cwd}")
     elif not quiet:
         print("\n✅ All checks passed")
 
     if as_json:
         print(json.dumps({"timestamp": datetime.now().isoformat(),
                           "execution_path": script_path, "cwd": cwd,
-                          "failures": FAIL, "healthy": len(FAIL) == 0}))
+                          "failures": FAIL, "report_only": REPORT_ONLY,
+                          "healthy": len(FAIL) == 0}))
 
     sys.exit(1 if FAIL else 0)
 

scripts/prose-lint.sh

@@ -87,11 +87,21 @@ echo "  ✅ IP consistency verified (.19=.122=.123 all reachable)"
 # Report provenance — every contract report must state the absolute path it
 # executed from, so a stale-consumer report is distinguishable from a real fault
 # at read time (2026-09-09 probe-drift incident: three false DEGRADED rounds).
-PROV_FILES=$(grep -rl '\*\*Report format\*\*' ./*.prose.md 2>/dev/null || true)
-if [ -n "$PROV_FILES" ]; then
+# Enforced only inside the **Report format** paragraph, and a check-health
+# contract with no Report format paragraph FAILs rather than being skipped.
+PROV_FILES=$(grep -rlE '^### check-health|\*\*Report format\*\*' ./*.prose.md 2>/dev/null || true)
+if [ -z "$PROV_FILES" ]; then
+  echo "  ❌ No check-health/report-format contracts found — provenance not enforced"
+  FAILED=1
+else
   PROV_BAD=0
   while IFS= read -r f; do
-    if ! grep -qE 'absolute path|pwd -P|executed from' "$f"; then
+    [ -n "$f" ] || continue
+    REPORT_PARA=$(awk '/\*\*Report format\*\*/{found=1} found{print} found && /^[[:space:]]*$/{exit}' "$f")
+    if [ -z "$REPORT_PARA" ]; then
+      echo "  ❌ $f: check-health contract has no **Report format** paragraph"
+      PROV_BAD=1
+    elif ! printf '%s\n' "$REPORT_PARA" | grep -qE 'absolute path|pwd -P|executed from'; then
       echo "  ❌ $f: **Report format** lacks execution provenance (absolute path / pwd -P)"
       PROV_BAD=1
     fi

tests/test_probe_drift.py

@@ -7,30 +7,46 @@ stale expectations rather than live faults.
     abiba (pi-only since the harness purge) was tested as a Hermes host, koby
     (report-only per the captain's 2026-08-17 ruling) was counted as repairable,
     koby's CT 111 was probed on amdpve where it does not exist (it runs on
-    storepve .6), and a .env-based hermes wrapper was FAILed for not mentioning
-    infisical.
+    storepve .6), and the wrapper infisical check had two bugs — it read only
+    the first 20 lines, so koonimo's wrapper (which references /usr/bin/infisical
+    past line 20) false-failed, and it treated koby's genuine no-infisical
+    (~/.hermes/.env) wrapper as broken.
   * gpu-monitor emitted "DEGRADED — GPU-rtx3090 000, GPU-rtx5070 000" three
     times from probing bare port 80 on GPU hosts while :8080 answered 200.
   * infrastructure-monitoring probed CT 116 for the PVE API (no pveproxy ->
     000) instead of the five real cluster nodes, which answer 401 = alive.
 
-These tests pin the corrections so the false alarms cannot return silently.
-They are static/structural over the contracts plus an inert import of the health
-script — no live network, vault, or SSH access is required.
+These tests execute the health script (with SSH/vault stubbed) and the real
+provenance consumer (scripts/prose-lint.sh), and parse the contracts' executable
+check-health probe blocks into normalized probe sets. No live network, vault, or
+SSH access is required.
 """
 from __future__ import annotations
 
 import importlib.util
+import json
+import os
 import pathlib
 import re
+import subprocess
+import sys
+import textwrap
 
 import pytest
 
 ROOT = pathlib.Path(__file__).resolve().parents[1]
 AHC = ROOT / "scripts" / "agent-health-check.py"
+LINT = ROOT / "scripts" / "prose-lint.sh"
 GPU = ROOT / "gpu-monitor.prose.md"
 INFRA = ROOT / "infrastructure-monitoring.prose.md"
-PROXMOX = ROOT / "proxmox-monitor.prose.md"
+
+PVE_NODE_IPS = {
+    "192.168.68.9",
+    "192.168.68.5",
+    "192.168.68.15",
+    "192.168.68.6",
+    "192.168.68.12",
+}
 
 
 @pytest.fixture(scope="module")
@@ -43,6 +59,26 @@ def ahc():
     return module
 
 
+# ── helpers: execute the health script with SSH/vault stubbed ─────────
+
+def _run_main(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys, argv, ssh_result=None):
+    ahc.FAIL.clear()
+    ahc.REPORT_ONLY.clear()
+    monkeypatch.setattr(ahc, "load_agent_keys", lambda: None)
+    monkeypatch.setattr(ahc, "ssh", lambda *a, **k: ssh_result)
+    monkeypatch.setattr(sys, "argv", ["agent-health-check.py", "--no-deploy", *argv])
+    with pytest.raises(SystemExit) as exc:
+        ahc.main()
+    return exc.value.code, capsys.readouterr().out
+
+
+def _json_payload(out):
+    for line in reversed(out.splitlines()):
+        if line.startswith('{"timestamp"'):
+            return json.loads(line)
+    raise AssertionError(f"no JSON payload in output:\n{out}")
+
+
 # ── agent-health-check: stale-expectation legs ───────────────────────
 
 def test_import_does_not_contact_vault(ahc):
@@ -68,17 +104,19 @@ def test_koby_ct111_is_on_storepve(ahc):
     assert ahc.AGENTS["koby"]["pve"] == "storepve"
 
 
-@pytest.mark.parametrize("agent", ["koby", "koonimo", "tanko"])
-def test_report_only_legs_never_count_as_failures(ahc, agent):
+def test_report_only_legs_never_count_as_failures(ahc):
+    for agent, report_only in (("koby", True), ("koonimo", False), ("tanko", False)):
         ahc.FAIL.clear()
-    try:
+        ahc.REPORT_ONLY.clear()
         ahc._fail(f"probe:{agent}", agent)
-        if ahc.AGENTS[agent].get("report_only"):
+        if report_only:
             assert ahc.FAIL == []
+            assert ahc.REPORT_ONLY == [f"probe:{agent}"]
         else:
             assert ahc.FAIL == [f"probe:{agent}"]
-    finally:
+            assert ahc.REPORT_ONLY == []
     ahc.FAIL.clear()
+    ahc.REPORT_ONLY.clear()
 
 
 def test_failure_recording_accepts_agentless_keys(ahc):
@@ -90,63 +128,237 @@ def test_failure_recording_accepts_agentless_keys(ahc):
         ahc.FAIL.clear()
 
 
-def test_script_reports_absolute_execution_provenance(ahc):
-    src = AHC.read_text()
-    assert "execution_path" in src
-    assert "os.getcwd()" in src
+def test_json_reports_absolute_execution_provenance(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys):
+    code, out = _run_main(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys, ["--json"])
+    payload = _json_payload(out)
+    assert payload["execution_path"] == os.path.abspath(str(AHC))
+    assert payload["cwd"] == os.getcwd()
+    assert code == 1  # stubbed SSH fails every leg, but provenance is still emitted
 
 
-def test_wrapper_check_has_no_bare_infisical_expectation(ahc):
-    # A wrapper that never mentions infisical (koonimo sources ~/.hermes/.env)
-    # must not be FAILed merely for lacking an infisical reference.
-    assert "wrapper resolves creds without infisical" in AHC.read_text()
+def test_quiet_run_still_carries_provenance_on_the_alert_path(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys):
+    # The production cron runs --quiet; a report without provenance is
+    # unactionable (item 4). Both the header line and the ALERT line must carry it.
+    code, out = _run_main(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys, ["--quiet"])
+    assert code == 1
+    assert "📍 executed from: script=" in out
+    alerts = [ln for ln in out.splitlines() if ln.startswith("ALERT agent-health:")]
+    assert alerts, out
+    assert f"script={os.path.abspath(str(AHC))}" in alerts[0]
+    assert f"cwd={os.getcwd()}" in alerts[0]
 
 
-# ── item 4: every contract report carries its execution path ──────────
+def test_json_surfaces_report_only_findings_separately(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys):
+    # Koby's down legs are reported but must not count as fleet failures; the
+    # --json payload exposes them in their own array (item 1 + f8).
+    _, out = _run_main(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys, ["--json"])
+    payload = _json_payload(out)
+    assert isinstance(payload["report_only"], list)
+    assert any(key.startswith(("gateway-down:koby", "ct-unreachable:koby"))
+               for key in payload["report_only"])
+    assert not any("koby" in key for key in payload["failures"])
 
-@pytest.mark.parametrize("contract", [GPU, INFRA, PROXMOX], ids=lambda p: p.name)
-def test_report_format_requires_execution_provenance(contract):
+
+# ── agent-health-check: wrapper infisical behavior (f3) ───────────────
+
+def _stub_wrapper_ssh(ahc, monkeypatch, wrapper_body, test_x_result="OK", command_v="/usr/local/bin/infisical"):
+    def fake_ssh(host, cmd, user="root"):
+        if cmd.startswith("cat /root/.local/bin/hermes"):
+            return wrapper_body
+        if cmd.startswith("ls -la /root/.local/bin/hermes "):
+            return "-rwxr-xr-x 1 root root 0 Jan 1 00:00 /root/.local/bin/hermes"
+        if cmd.startswith("ls -la /root/.local/bin/hermes-real") or "venv/bin/hermes" in cmd:
+            return "-rwxr-xr-x 1 root root 0 Jan 1 00:00 /root/.local/bin/hermes-real"
+        if cmd.startswith("grep -c 'LITELLM_API_KEY'"):
+            return "1"
+        if cmd.startswith("test -x "):
+            return test_x_result
+        if cmd.startswith("command -v infisical"):
+            return command_v
+        return None
+
+    monkeypatch.setattr(ahc, "ssh", fake_ssh)
+    monkeypatch.setattr(ahc, "AGENTS", {"koonimo": dict(ahc.AGENTS["koonimo"])})
+    ahc.FAIL.clear()
+    ahc.REPORT_ONLY.clear()
+
+
+def test_env_based_wrapper_without_infisical_is_not_failed(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys):
+    _stub_wrapper_ssh(ahc, monkeypatch,
+                      "#!/bin/bash\nsource ~/.hermes/.env\nexec hermes-real \"$@\"\n")
+    ahc.check_wrapper_integrity()
+    out = capsys.readouterr().out
+    assert ahc.FAIL == []
+    assert "wrapper resolves creds without infisical" in out
+
+
+def test_dangling_absolute_infisical_path_is_failed(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys):
+    # Wrapper hardcodes /usr/bin/infisical, which is absent, while PATH resolves
+    # infisical to /usr/local/bin/infisical. The literal path must be verified,
+    # not inferred from PATH resolution.
+    _stub_wrapper_ssh(ahc, monkeypatch,
+                      "#!/bin/bash\n/usr/bin/infisical run -- hermes-real \"$@\"\n",
+                      test_x_result="MISS", command_v="/usr/local/bin/infisical")
+    ahc.check_wrapper_integrity()
+    assert "wrapper-infisical-path:koonimo" in ahc.FAIL
+
+
+def test_existing_absolute_infisical_path_passes(ahc, monkeypatch, capsys):
+    _stub_wrapper_ssh(ahc, monkeypatch,
+                      "#!/bin/bash\n/usr/bin/infisical run -- hermes-real \"$@\"\n",
+                      test_x_result="OK")
+    ahc.check_wrapper_integrity()
+    out = capsys.readouterr().out
+    assert ahc.FAIL == []
+    assert "wrapper infisical path OK" in out
+
+
+# ── item 4: prose-lint enforces report provenance (real consumer) ─────
+
+GOOD_CONTRACT = textwrap.dedent("""\
+    ---
+    kind: function
+    name: good
+    description: fixture with provenance
+    ---
+
+    ## Parameters
+
+    - x: y
+
+    ## Returns
+
+    ok
+
+    ### check-health
+
+    ```bash
+    pwd -P
+    ```
+
+    **Report format**: Begin with the absolute path the probe executed from.
+    """)
+
+DECOY_CONTRACT = textwrap.dedent("""\
+    ---
+    kind: function
+    name: decoy
+    description: fixture with provenance only outside the report format
+    ---
+
+    ## Parameters
+
+    - x: y
+
+    ## Returns
+
+    ok
+
+    The absolute path of the config is /etc/foo.
+
+    ### check-health
+
+    ```bash
+    true
+    ```
+
+    **Report format**: Summarize actual results from each probe.
+    """)
+
+MISSING_CONTRACT = textwrap.dedent("""\
+    ---
+    kind: function
+    name: missing
+    description: check-health contract with no report format
+    ---
+
+    ## Parameters
+
+    - x: y
+
+    ## Returns
+
+    ok
+
+    ### check-health
+
+    ```bash
+    pwd -P
+    ```
+    """)
+
+
+def _run_lint(tmp_path, text, name):
+    (tmp_path / name).write_text(text)
+    return subprocess.run(["bash", str(LINT)], cwd=tmp_path,
+                          capture_output=True, text=True)
+
+
+def test_prose_lint_accepts_report_format_with_provenance(tmp_path):
+    result = _run_lint(tmp_path, GOOD_CONTRACT, "good.prose.md")
+    assert result.returncode == 0, result.stdout + result.stderr
+
+
+def test_prose_lint_rejects_report_format_without_provenance(tmp_path):
+    result = _run_lint(tmp_path, DECOY_CONTRACT, "decoy.prose.md")
+    assert result.returncode == 1, result.stdout
+    assert "lacks execution provenance" in result.stdout
+
+
+def test_prose_lint_requires_report_format_on_check_health_contract(tmp_path):
+    result = _run_lint(tmp_path, MISSING_CONTRACT, "missing.prose.md")
+    assert result.returncode == 1, result.stdout
+    assert "no **Report format** paragraph" in result.stdout
+
+
+# ── contracts: parse the executable check-health probe block ─────────
+
+def _check_health_block(contract):
+    """Extract the bash probe block under ### check-health (the probe interface)."""
     text = contract.read_text()
-    assert "**Report format**" in text
-    assert re.search(r"absolute path|pwd -P|executed from", text)
+    marker = "### check-health"
+    assert marker in text, f"{contract.name} has no {marker}"
+    after = text.split(marker, 1)[1]
+    match = re.search(r"```bash\n(.*?)```", after, re.S)
+    assert match, f"{contract.name} check-health has no bash probe block"
+    return match.group(1)
 
 
-# ── item 3: gpu-monitor probes the real GPU endpoints ────────────────
-
-def test_gpu_monitor_probes_gpu_health_on_8080():
-    text = GPU.read_text()
-    assert "http://192.168.68.8:8080/health" in text
-    assert "http://192.168.68.110:8080/health" in text
+def _urls(block):
+    # Comments document the forbidden/deprecated probes; only count real commands.
+    code = "\n".join(ln for ln in block.splitlines()
+                     if not ln.lstrip().startswith("#"))
+    return set(re.findall(r"https?://[^\s\"')]+", code))
 
 
-def test_gpu_monitor_forbids_bare_port_80_on_gpu_hosts():
-    text = GPU.read_text()
-    assert re.search(r"never .{0,20}bare port 80", text, re.I)
-    # The false-DEGRADED symptom must be documented, not just implied.
-    assert "DEGRADED" in text
+def test_gpu_monitor_probes_every_gpu_health_on_8080():
+    block = _check_health_block(GPU)
+    gpu_health = {u for u in _urls(block) if ":8080/health" in u}
+    assert {"http://192.168.68.8:8080/health",
+            "http://192.168.68.110:8080/health"} <= gpu_health
+
+
+def test_gpu_monitor_never_probes_bare_port_80_on_gpu_hosts():
+    block = _check_health_block(GPU)
+    bare = {u for u in _urls(block)
+            if re.match(r"https?://192\.168\.68\.(8|110|15)/", u)}
+    assert bare == set()
+    assert re.search(r"never .{0,40}bare port 80", block, re.I)
 
 
 def test_gpu_monitor_documents_router_301_as_alive():
-    text = GPU.read_text()
-    assert "/gpu/gpu-data" in text
-    assert "301" in text
+    block = _check_health_block(GPU)
+    assert "/health/unified" in block
+    assert "301" in block
 
 
-# ── item 2: infrastructure-monitoring PVE API vantage ────────────────
+def test_infra_monitoring_probes_every_real_pve_node():
+    block = _check_health_block(INFRA)
+    match = re.search(r"for node in ([^\n;]+)", block)
+    assert match, "PVE liveness loop not found in check-health"
+    assert set(match.group(1).split()) == PVE_NODE_IPS
+    assert "https://$node:8006/api2/json/version" in block
+
 
 def test_infra_monitoring_does_not_probe_ct116_for_pve_api():
-    assert "https://192.168.68.116:8006" not in INFRA.read_text()
-
-
-@pytest.mark.parametrize(
-    "node",
-    ["192.168.68.9", "192.168.68.5", "192.168.68.15", "192.168.68.6", "192.168.68.12"],
-)
-def test_infra_monitoring_probes_every_real_pve_node(node):
-    assert node in INFRA.read_text()
-
-
-def test_infra_monitoring_uses_any_http_liveness_rule():
-    text = INFRA.read_text()
-    assert "api2/json/version" in text
-    assert "ANY HTTP status" in text or "any-HTTP" in text
+    assert "192.168.68.116:8006" not in _check_health_block(INFRA)